Cromolyn vs Ketotifen and other Antihistamines for MCAS

What is the difference between Cromolyn and Antihistamines? 

Mast Cell Activation Syndrome (MCAS) can cause a wide range of symptoms due to the overactive release of inflammatory substances like histamine, prostaglandins, and cytokines. Managing MCAS often involves medications that help stabilize mast cells or block the effects of histamine. Three common medications in this area are Ketotifen, Cromolyn Sodium, and antihistamines. Let’s break down how each works, their uses, and potential side effects.

Ketotifen: A Dual Action Mast Cell Stabilizer and Antihistamine

Ketotifen is a unique medication because it stabilizes mast cells and also works as an antihistamine (H1 receptor blocker). It has been used for decades, particularly in Europe and Canada, for conditions like asthma, allergic rhinitis, and mast cell disorders. Ketotifen helps reduce the release of histamine and other inflammatory mediators from mast cells, which can alleviate symptoms like itching, hives, and gastrointestinal issues.

Uses:

• Effective in treating MCAS, especially when patients have widespread symptoms involving the skin, gastrointestinal system, and respiratory tract.
• Helps reduce nighttime histamine symptoms like night sweats.
• Compounded versions (capsules, liquids, or creams) are available in some regions, as it's not widely commercially available in the U.S.

Side Effects:

• Drowsiness is a common issue, especially when starting the medication. However, some people find that this subsides after a few weeks.
• Some individuals may experience weight gain or appetite changes​​.

Advantages:

• It can address both mast cell instability and histamine-related symptoms.
• A good option for people experiencing symptoms like night sweats, itching, and rashes​​.

Cromolyn Sodium: The Mast Cell Stabilizer

Cromolyn Sodium is a mast cell stabilizer commonly used for gastrointestinal symptoms in MCAS. It works by preventing mast cells from releasing inflammatory substances like histamine, which can help reduce symptoms related to food allergies, irritable bowel syndrome, and other gastrointestinal issues. Unlike Ketotifen, Cromolyn doesn’t have antihistamine properties, making it purely a mast cell stabilizer.

Uses:

• Often prescribed for gastrointestinal symptoms like bloating, diarrhea, and abdominal pain in MCAS patients​​.
• Available as an oral solution (Gastrocrom®), but can also be compounded into capsules for individuals sensitive to liquid formulations.
• Cromolyn is typically used as a second-line therapy when other treatments like antihistamines or dietary changes aren't sufficient.

Side Effects:

• Cromolyn has few side effects but may initially worsen symptoms when first started, especially at higher doses. This usually improves as the body adjusts.
• In rare cases, it can cause nausea or a metallic taste​​.

Advantages:

• It’s considered safe and well-tolerated for long-term use.
• Ideal for patients whose symptoms are primarily gastrointestinal​.

Antihistamines: The Backbone of Symptom Relief

Antihistamines are often the first-line treatment for MCAS because they block the effects of histamine, which is one of the primary mediators released by mast cells. There are two types: H1 blockers (like Cetirizine and Diphenhydramine) and H2 blockers (like Famotidine), both of which are frequently used in combination.

H1 Blockers:

• Second-generation antihistamines (e.g., Cetirizine/Zyrtec, Loratadine/Claritin) are usually preferred due to their minimal sedative effects. They are effective in controlling skin symptoms like itching and flushing, and some patients with MCAS may require higher doses than typically recommended​​.
• First-generation antihistamines (e.g., Diphenhydramine/Benadryl) are stronger but tend to cause drowsiness and are generally reserved for emergency situations or severe flares​.

H2 Blockers:

• These target histamine receptors in the stomach and can help with gastrointestinal symptoms like acid reflux, nausea, and cramping. Famotidine (Pepcid) and Cimetidine (Tagamet) are common examples​​.

Side Effects:

• First-generation antihistamines can cause drowsiness and cognitive impairment.
• Second-generation antihistamines are better tolerated but may still cause mild fatigue or dry mouth​.

Advantages:

• Widely available, affordable, and easy to use.
• Effective at managing acute allergic-type symptoms such as hives, flushing, and itching​​.

Which One is Best for You?

Each of these medications can be effective for different symptoms associated with MCAS. For example:

• If your symptoms are mostly skin-related or you struggle with nighttime histamine release, Ketotifen might be your best choice.
• For gastrointestinal issues, Cromolyn Sodium could be the most effective option.
• Antihistamines are a good starting point for general histamine-related symptoms like flushing, itching, and respiratory issues.

For many people, a combination of these medications works best, as MCAS can affect multiple systems at once. Always talk to your doctor about which medications might be right for your specific symptom profile and health needs.

‍

‍

FAQ

What is the difference between Cromolyn and Ketotifen?

Cromolyn is a mast cell stabilizer that primarily helps prevent the release of inflammatory mediators, which makes it effective for gastrointestinal symptoms in MCAS. Ketotifen, on the other hand, is both a mast cell stabilizer and an antihistamine, making it effective for a broader range of symptoms, including skin and respiratory issues.

What is the new treatment for Mast Cell Activation Syndrome (MCAS)?

Currently, there are no specific "new" treatments for MCAS. The treatment is individualized and often involves a combination of medications like antihistamines, mast cell stabilizers (such as Ketotifen and Cromolyn), and lifestyle adjustments. Some patients may benefit from newer biologic treatments like Omalizumab (Xolair), which targets IgE, a part of the immune response.

What are the best natural mast cell stabilizers?

Natural mast cell stabilizers include quercetin, luteolin, and vitamin C. These bioflavonoids can help reduce the release of histamine and other inflammatory substances from mast cells.

Does Ketotifen stabilize mast cells?

Yes, Ketotifen stabilizes mast cells by preventing them from releasing inflammatory mediators such as histamine. This dual action as both a mast cell stabilizer and an antihistamine makes it a popular choice for managing MCAS.

Why is Cromolyn no longer available?

Cromolyn is still available, but some forms, such as inhalers for asthma, have been discontinued in certain markets due to manufacturing issues or reduced demand. However, it is still available as an oral solution or compounded into capsules for MCAS.

What does Cromolyn do for MCAS?

Cromolyn Sodium stabilizes mast cells, preventing the release of inflammatory mediators like histamine and leukotrienes. It is particularly effective for managing gastrointestinal symptoms in MCAS, such as nausea, bloating, and diarrhea​.

Is Ketotifen a strong antihistamine?

Ketotifen is considered a moderately strong antihistamine. It is not as potent as first-generation antihistamines like Diphenhydramine (Benadryl), but it is effective and causes fewer sedative effects than some stronger antihistamines.

Does Ketotifen suppress the immune system?

No, Ketotifen does not suppress the immune system. It stabilizes mast cells to prevent the release of inflammatory mediators without compromising the overall function of the immune system.

What is a serious side effect of Cromolyn?

A serious but rare side effect of Cromolyn can be anaphylaxis, an allergic reaction. It is generally well-tolerated, but some people may experience skin rashes, nausea, or difficulty breathing.

What is equivalent to Cromolyn?

Nedocromil is often considered a close equivalent to Cromolyn as it also functions as a mast cell stabilizer. However, Cromolyn remains the more widely used mast cell stabilizer for conditions like MCAS.

What organ does Cromolyn Sodium affect?

Cromolyn Sodium mainly affects the gastrointestinal tract when taken orally, helping to prevent symptoms like nausea and bloating caused by mast cell activation. It can also impact the lungs when used as an inhaler for asthma management.

How did I cure my Mast Cell Activation Syndrome?

Currently, there is no cure for MCAS, but many patients manage the condition with a combination of medications (like mast cell stabilizers and antihistamines), dietary changes, and avoiding known triggers.

Does Cromolyn make you gain weight?

Weight gain is not a commonly reported side effect of Cromolyn. Most patients tolerate it well, though mild side effects like nausea or headaches are possible.

Does Cromolyn suppress the immune system?

No, Cromolyn Sodium does not suppress the immune system. It acts specifically to prevent the release of mast cell mediators without affecting other aspects of immune function.

Is Cromolyn or Ketotifen better?

The choice between Cromolyn and Ketotifen depends on the symptoms being treated. Cromolyn is more effective for gastrointestinal symptoms, while Ketotifen may be better for skin-related and respiratory symptoms due to its additional antihistamine effects.

What is the root cause of MCAS?

The root cause of MCAS is the abnormal activation and degranulation of mast cells, which can be triggered by various factors including allergens, stress, environmental factors, and sometimes genetic predisposition.

What drugs worsen MCAS?

Certain drugs, like opioids, NSAIDs (e.g., ibuprofen), and some antibiotics, can worsen MCAS symptoms by triggering mast cell activation.

Is quercetin more effective than Cromolyn?

Some studies suggest that quercetin, a natural bioflavonoid, may be more effective at inhibiting mast cell activation than Cromolyn, particularly for skin and respiratory symptoms​.

What is the best anti-inflammatory for MCAS?

For MCAS, medications like Leukotriene inhibitors (e.g., Montelukast) are often used as anti-inflammatories, targeting the inflammation caused by mast cell mediators like leukotrienes.

What calms an MCAS flare?

During an MCAS flare, increasing doses of antihistamines (both H1 and H2 blockers) and using mast cell stabilizers like Cromolyn or Ketotifen can help. Benadryl is often used as a rescue medication in emergencies.

References

1. "Mast Cell Activation Syndrome (MCAS)." The EDS Clinic, February 2024, www.eds.clinic/articles/treatment-of-mast-cell-disease.
2. Weng, Zhiqiang, et al. "Quercetin Is More Effective than Cromolyn in Blocking Human Mast Cell Cytokine Release and Inhibits Contact Dermatitis and Photosensitivity in Humans." PLOS ONE, vol. 7, no. 3, 2012, e33805. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0033805.
3. Minutello, Kathleen, and Vikash Gupta. "Cromolyn Sodium." StatPearls, updated 2022, www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK557473/.
4. Molderings, Gerald J., et al. "Pharmacological Treatment Options for Mast Cell Activation Disease." Naunyn-Schmiedeberg's Archives of Pharmacology, vol. 389, no. 7, 2016, pp. 671-694. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00210-016-1247-1.